|
21st CENTURY' SERIES, NO. 14
GROWING UP 'HEALTHY IN BODY AND MIND': WHAT
IT MEANS FOR TODAY'S CHILDREN
| 1. |
An Outline of the Government's Initial
and New 'Angel Plans' |
| |
According to a report released by the Ministry of Health,
Labour and Welfare's National Institute of Population and
Social Security Research on 30 January 2002, the Total Fertility
Rate for Japanese women*1
was 1.36 in the year 2000. It is predicted to fall to 1.31
in 2007 and then stabilise long term at 1.39 from 2030. This
is a marked reduction in the figures since the last long-term
birth rate forecast of 1.61 issued in 1997. The number of
babies born in 2000 was 1.19 million, however it will fall
below the million mark in 2014 and it is estimated it will
be 667,000 in 2050, when the total population will fall to
100,590,000.
The government felt a sense of crisis and took urgent measures
to deal with the declining birth rate in the year following
1993, when the birth rate fell to a record low of 1.46. The
number of babies born in Japan in 1993 was 1,180,000, less
than half the 2,680,000 babies born in 1947 immediately after
the war. In December 1994 the 'Angel Plan' ('The Fundamental
Plan for Child Rearing Support') was put into place by agreement
between the then Ministries of Education, Health and Welfare
and Construction. Further, as part of the implementation of
the Plan, the 'Basic Proposal for Urgent Child Care Measures'
(Urgent Child Care Five Year Project) was established by agreement
between the Ministers of Finance, Health and Welfare and Home
Affairs as a plan for the promotion of the Angel Plan. The
aim of the Angel Plan was to respond to the increase in the
number of households where both parents work and, in relation
to the nuclear family:
| 1. |
Raise consciousness throughout the whole of
society in order to promote child rearing support
programmes in local society, business and the workplace
|
| 2. |
Establish basic policy and key issue plans
between the Education, Health and Welfare and Construction
Ministries for a ten year plan for child rearing support
measures and conduct systematic general promotion
of those measures
|
| 3. |
Design the foundations for measures promoting
programmes specifically suited to the characteristics
of the regions, such as systematic child rearing support
programmes promoted by local governments. |
Following the initial 'Angel Plan' the six Ministers for Finance,
Education, Health and Welfare, Labour, Construction and Home
Affairs agreed in December 1999 at the 'Declining Birth Rate
Measures Promotion Ministerial Conference' on important measures
for concrete implementation based on the 'Declining Birth
Rate Measures Promotion Basic Plan' and these implementation
measures became known as the 'New Angel Plan'. The main points
of the new plan were:
| 1. |
The boosting of child rearing support services
such as child care services
|
| 2. |
The improvement of the employment environment
to facilitate women's participation in the workforce
|
| 3. |
Redressing the workplace culture of work taking
priority over family and strict division of roles according
to gender
|
| 4. |
The review of the health system specific to
women and children
|
| 5. |
The review of the education environment influencing
children in the regions
|
| 6. |
The putting into place of an educational environment
which produces children who are free from anxiety
|
| 7. |
The lessening of the financial burden which
accompanies educating children
|
| 8. |
Support for child rearing through housing reform
and town planning. |
The government's plan is to focus on increasing the number
of children by:
| 1. |
Dealing with a birth rate that is declining
more sharply than national estimates by putting into
place a number of environmental improvements to assist
the bearing and raising of children
|
| 2. |
Improving the maternity leave, workforce re-entry
and child endowment systems in recognition of barriers
preventing child bearing and rearing. These barriers
are the uncertainty in relation to both current and
future livelihoods caused by the prolonged recession,
increases in restructuring and unemployment and the
introduction of the 401K Defined Contribution Pension
Plan.
|
| 3. |
Improving the physical and mental support system
for parents in recognition of the fact that lack of
confidence and child rearing stress is caused by the
trend towards nuclear families. |
Viewed from the perspective of the national economic growth
rate, employment security and the stability of the Japanese
lifestyle, these national policies not only answer the problems
of the next generation, who will be responsible for the future,
they are also exceedingly logical. Nonetheless, in today's times
when world ideological trends are changing, values and perceptions
of civilization are in conflict and Japan's individual historical
national culture and identity are being re-thought, it is crucial
to first ask what kind of children we should be raising our
children to be. In the 21st century it is insufficient to raise
'healthy' children (and therefore citizens) by simply providing
satisfactory food, clothing and shelter. This is particularly
the case that where a populace needs to be attuned to the trends
and philosophy of the times and have acquired a global, international
perspective and this is what will ensure the survival of Japan.
|
| 2. |
Understanding 'Healthy in Body and
Mind' |
| |
Japan has in place the Child Welfare Law in relation to the
nurturing and welfare of the children who hold the future
in their hands. This Child Welfare Law set out the principles
of child welfare in Article 1:
| '(1) |
All citizens must make efforts to ensure that
children are born and also raised healthy in body and
mind
|
| (2) |
All children shall be equally guaranteed the
quality of life in (1) and lovingly protected'
|
In relation to the responsibility for nurturing children
Article 2 states, 'The national and local governments shall,
together with the guardians of children, bear the responsibility
for ensuring that children are raised healthy in body and
mind'. In these articles of legislation the next generation's
children are guaranteed by law birth, nurturing, quality of
life and loving protection that are 'healthy in body and mind'.
The difficulty is to define the content of 'healthy in body
and mind'. It is not possible to find any concrete document
or government opinion analysing or explaining the content
of the term. This definitional issue is of vital concern.
My personal view is that if children are nurtured
and protected from the following standpoint they will have
principles and a philosophy appropriate to the times and a
global, international perspective. In other words, these are
the prerequisites with which the next generation of Japanese
citizens should be furnished. 'Body and mind' indicates both
mental and physical aspects. The physical aspect means the
fulfilment of physical strength and vitality appropriate to
the stage of growth, being 'fit as a fiddle'. This is something
that can be studied comparatively from statistics for Japan
and also in an international context. Accordingly it is not
difficult to discover the current level of physical health
of Japan's children. The difficulty lies in the mental 'health'
area. There are differing opinions concerning the standpoint
and fields one should use in analysing mental health. However
support can be gained at least in relation to the definition
from the perspective of the legislation. It may be that legislation
is the citizens' set of minimum rules, since they involve
coercion and this is the departure point for my argument.
My point is that 'healthy' children can be defined in the
following way according to position of Japanese citizens under
the Japanese constitution.
Firstly, there is no argument concerning the fact that
Japan's citizens aim at the ideal human characteristics that
modern developed countries pursue. This is based on the notion
that the roots of all values are in the human character. It
is embodied in Article 13 of the Constitution, which has as
its purpose respect for the individual. It emphasizes the
idea that one's own character and another's character are
of equal value, and that to pursue self expression ceaselessly
is always something done in consideration of the conflict
that might occur with others' interests, so that it is never
appropriate to seek one's own gain at another's expense. In
other words this is the antithesis of the culture of blaming
others when an impediment occurs when one is doing what one
wants to do. In current social conditions it is embarrassing
to even say the expressions 'apply oneself diligently to one's
studies' and 'perseverance and determination' and 'comeback
from a defeat with renewed vigour'. It used to be a virtue
within Japan's cultural identity to overcome whatever challenges
lay in one's path, treating them as the nourishment of one's
improvement. The reality is that this traditional Japanese
culture is contained within the individualism and individual
responsibility found in the 'respect for the individual' in
Article 13.
Secondly, modern international society is both internally
and externally constructed on the foundation of the sovereignty
of the citizens. Internally this means the power structure
(separation of powers) guarantees the citizens' pursuit of
happiness; externally it means the justification for the right
to assert the sovereignty of the nation state itself (external
independence) is the substance of the citizens' sovereignty.
The next generation of children who will be Japan's citizens
must master this dual faceted principle. Internally speaking,
we the people are the main actors of the nation and must use
the formation and expression of responsible political opinions
with the aim of realising the principles of democracy and
freedom. In an external sense we must become aware of the
right to assert Japan's independence and peace (the national
interest) to other countries (the problem of the right of
self-defence).
Thirdly, modern global society is a collection of
numerous countries that each asserts national sovereignty.
The 189 countries of the United Nations assert their own country's
interests whilst making allowances for the interests of others,
with the aim of leading a peaceful existence. It will be necessary
for the children who will be the next generation of Japanese
citizens to make efforts to understand the legal tenets of
international relations without sacrificing other countries
or taking Japan's peace or interests lightly and ensuring
that national sovereignty is realised with equality (the problem
of collective self-defence). This concept is stated in the
preamble to the Japanese Constitution as one to which 'obedience...is
incumbent upon all nations who would sustain their own sovereignty
and justify their sovereign relationship with other nations'
|
| 3. |
The Positioning of the Governments
'New Angel Plan' |
| |
By defining nurturing and welfare that is 'healthy in body
and mind' in this way the policies that form the 'New Angel
Plan' become clear in a concrete sense. In other words the
'New Angel Plan' is carried out as various measures under
the policies in order to achieve the goal of putting into
place nurturing and welfare that is 'healthy in body and mind'
through child care for children from birth to school age (including
those of pre-school age) and for children of school age. The
key point in this context is that parents, child care workers
and pre-school teachers have the primary responsibility for
children's healthy nurturing and welfare from the mental aspect
(the 'citizen's right to education') and that this duty is
an extremely important one. It must be understood that this
duty is actually of more significance than secondary education
and reform of tertiary education, as it impacts the fate of
Japan's citizenry. Government policy assumes that this educational
duty incumbent on parents, child care workers and pre-school
teachers will be carried out and at best limits itself to
improving the nurturing and welfare environment and financial
support. The point of concern is that there are currently
problems with the running of child care centres. Firstly,
in relation to management itself, within currently approved
child care centres there are public child care centres run
by local governments and private child care centres approved
at a prefectural level which meet standards set by the Ministry
of Health, Labour and Welfare (operated by social welfare
bodies). In the former case local government public servants
provide the childcare itself and private childcare centres
also follow this pattern. It is more appropriate to allow
them to be operated privately. The certified childcare to
be put into place by the Tokyo municipality from fiscal 2002*2
is a desirable format in this sense. Secondly, having local
governments provide operating conditions such as facilities
and operating expenses should not breach Article 89 of the
Constitution if it is done in accordance with the purport
of Articles 25 and 26.
|
| 4. |
The Responsibility of Parents, Child
Care Workers and Pre-School Teachers for Nurturing |
| |
What kind of conditions should parents, childcare workers
and pre-school teachers who bear responsibility as carers
of children fulfil? What kind of attributes and strengths
should they be trained in and what kind of nurturing methods
should they use in order to have children enjoy 'nurturing
and welfare that is healthy in body and mind'?
The role of parents should be considered firstly. All parents
should have unlimited love for their own children. The love
of a parent for a child is the expression of a basic instinct
that does not rely on calculation or logic and is an emotion
common to almost all animals. However examples of deficiency
in this parental love towards a child, which should be instinctive,
do appear and are broadcast by the mass media. It is a matter
of grave importance if there is a cause and effect relationship
between the speedy development of material civilisation, which
is an important means by which human beings pursue happiness
and the phenomena of deficient parental love. Modern parents
cannot live without enjoying the fruits of material civilisation
but as carers responsible for nurturing children they cannot
allow themselves to be drowned in those sweet fruits. The
fruits of modern science have brought abundance in food, clothing
and shelter to mankind, but to the marked detriment of our
original animal instincts. In order to repair the damage we
must resolve the problem by the study of the theory of modern
science, assessing its merits and demerits with firm resolve.
Simply reminiscing about the sound child rearing practices
of the past will not bring those days back.
Secondly the role of childcare workers and pre-school teachers
must also be examined. The government revised the Child Welfare
Law in the temporary Diet session of autumn 2001 elevating
childcare worker to a nationally accredited qualification.*3
If the importance of the next generation is considered the
question of how to put into effect the necessary skills for
these workers becomes urgent. Beginning with the 'Best 30'
plan tertiary education reform appears daily in the newspapers
under the catch phrases 'Nation of Excellence in Human Resources'
and 'Intellectual Property Nation'. However, the 'Human Resources
Abundant in Creativity' referred to earlier are more important
for the future of the nation.
|
*1 Total Fertility Rate:
The average number of children a woman will bear in her lifetime.
It is calculated by totalling the birth rate amongst women aged
15 to 49 recorded by age in a given year. The figure was 1.36
in 2000. If the figure does not rise above the 'population replacement
level' of 2.08, the population will not increase. The rate in
the US was 2.06 in 1998 and 1.72 in the UK in 1997.
*2 In Tokyo private individuals
and companies have been approved as operators of child care centres
since 2001 and the city provides financial support to those centres
which meet the city's own standards, such centres being called
'Approved Child Care Centres'. As of January 2002 there are 17
Approved Child Care Centres in Tokyo being run by private companies
and 19 being run by private individuals.
*3 The accreditation
is to be put into effect from November 2002. The written examination
involves 7 subjects: Social Welfare, Child Welfare, Developmental
Psychology and Mental Health, Children's Insurance, Children's
Nutrition, Principles of Child Care, Principles of Education and
Protective Care. Practical work experience must also be undertaken.
Male and female high school graduates may apply to take the examination,
there being no need for a university qualification.
|